Say it ain’t so
Melinda gone? How could it happen. Mary C. Matthews, producer of Idol Critic, explained it to me in email: “Did we really expect a nation that voted GWB in TWICE to at least choose an American Idol wisely?”
Tags: americanidol, idolcritic

May 17th, 2007 at 12:54 pm
No, Melinda was totally the GOP contestant. Old-fashioned and safe. Stuck in the past. Blake is a Progressive, always looking forward and trying to make things better. Last night’s results were a referendum on the Bush administration and the old boys network as much as the ‘06 elections were.
May 17th, 2007 at 1:15 pm
““Did we really expect a nation that voted GWB in TWICE to at least choose an American Idol wisely?—
That’s some sort of perfect storm of 2007 idiocy.